What does juror 8 say about the El train?
Once they’ve calmed down, Juror #8 explains why it’s impossible for the old neighbor living below the kid to have heard the kid yell, “I’ll kill you.” A neighbor said a train was passing by at the time of the murder and the train would have been way too loud for the man downstairs to hear voices.
What was the woman’s testimony in 12 Angry Men?
Juror #4 says he still says Guilty because of the testimony of the woman from across the street, who specifically says she saw the boy grip the knife overhanded and stab his father with a downwards motion. Juror #3 agrees with him.
What did the old man see 12 Angry Men?
So the new story is that the old man heard the boy fighting with his dad earlier in the night, heard the body hit the floor above his apartment, rushed to the door and assumed the boy was running away.
What does 12 Angry Men say about justice?
One man is dead. The life of another is at stake. If there is a reasonable doubt in your minds as to the guilt of the accused . . . then you must declare him not guilty. If, however, there is no reasonable doubt, then he must be found guilty.
Why is Juror 8 a good juror?
By the end of the movie, Juror #8 has proven himself to be a true hero for standing by his principles and having the courage and skill to put them to work. He eventually gets the jury to find the defendant Not Guilty, and in the process, he avoids sending an innocent 18 year-old kid to jail.
How does the discussion about the train make the old man’s testimony less trustworthy?
He mentions she remembered the most insignificant details . What does the discussion about the el train call into question about the old man’s testimony? The train makes so much noise it would not have been possible for the old man to hear the boy shout at his father “I’m going to kill you.”
Why is Juror 8 a hero?
What is the connection between the El train noise and the old man’s testimony?
What does the discussion about the el train call into question about the old man’s testimony? The train makes so much noise it would not have been possible for the old man to hear the boy shout at his father “I’m going to kill you.”
How are father son relationships important in 12 Angry Men?
The dysfunctional dynamic between father and son raises questions about the nature of parental authority and its abuses while also providing a possible motive for the murder. The relationship between the 3rd Juror and his son mirrors the abusive dynamic of the accused and his father.
Who is the janitor in Juror 8?
Cast
| Tae In-Ho | Rie Young-Zin | Kim Sun-Young |
| judge | trial prosecutor | janitor |
What seems to disprove the idea that the boy should have remembered the movies he was at that night?
What seems disprove the idea that the boy should have remembered the movie he was at that night? The fact that the boy was really emotionally stressed and his father was lying on the ground dead in front of him.
Who is the oldest Juror in 12 Angry Men?
Juror 9
As the jurors enter the room, it’s evident that Juror 9 is the oldest of the group. Even without saying anything, most readers and viewers will have assumptions about Juror 9 because of his age.
How does the discussion about the train call the old man’s testimony into question 12 Angry Men?
Is The Last juror a true story?
Plot introduction. The story is set in the fictional town of Clanton, Mississippi from 1970 to 1979.
What is a good quote from Twelve Angry Men?
Twelve Angry Men Quotes Showing 1-9 of 9 “It takes a great deal of courage to stand alone even if you believe in something very strongly.” ― Reginald Rose, Twelve Angry Men tags: courage, justice, responsibility
What did Juror Number 8 say about the El-train?
Juror #3 : [ to Juror #8 about the El-Train drowning out the supposed death threat ] You’re talkin’ about a matter of *seconds!* Nobody can be *that* accurate! Juror #8 : Well, I think testimony that can put a boy into the electric chair *should* be that accurate. Interesting?
What does the movie 12 Angry Men say about society?
Let these 12 Angry Men quotes make you realize how society rots with racism, prejudice, and ignorance. 12 Angry Men is a 1957 courtroom drama movie based on a teleplay of the same name by Reginald Rose. It is a powerful story about a group of 12 men deciding the fate of an 18-year-old defendant.